Do I Need Hurricane Shutters if I Have Impact Windows?

By Published On: May 8, 2023Categories: Home Tips, Impact Windows
custom impact windows

When it comes to protecting your home from hurricanes and other intense storms, there are various options to choose from. Hurricane shutters and impact windows are two popular choices. 

But if you have impact windows installed, do you really need hurricane shutters? Let’s take a closer look.

What are Hurricane Shutters?

Hurricane shutters vs impact windows

When it comes to protecting your windows during a hurricane, there are various options available to homeowners. One popular choice is to install hurricane shutters. Hurricane shutters are designed to protect your windows from high winds and flying debris during a hurricane. They are installed over your windows to shield them from damage and can be easily removed when not in use.

Many different types of hurricane shutters are available on the market, each with its own benefits and drawbacks. Some of the most common types of hurricane shutters include:

  1. Accordion shutters: These shutters have interlocking vertical blades that fold together like an accordion. They are typically made of metal or polycarbonate and can be quickly and easily deployed when a hurricane is approaching.
  2. Roll-down shutters: Roll-down shutters are typically made of aluminum or steel and are mounted above the window. They roll down on tracks to cover the window and can be operated either manually or with an electric motor.
  3. Colonial shutters: Colonial shutters are hinged shutters mounted to the side of the window and swing shut to cover the window. They are often made of wood or vinyl and can be customized to match the architectural style of your home.
  4. Bahama shutters: Bahama shutters are similar to colonial shutters but are mounted above the window and open outward like an awning. They are often made of aluminum and can provide shade and protection during a hurricane.
  5. Panel shutters: Panel shutters are made of plywood or metal panels that are screwed or bolted to the window frame. They are typically the least expensive type of hurricane shutter but can be time-consuming to install and remove.

Each type of hurricane shutter has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the best type for your home will depend on a variety of factors, including your budget, the style of your home, and the level of protection you require.

What are Impact Windows?

hurricane window shutter

Impact windows are designed to withstand the high winds and debris during a hurricane or other severe weather event. They are made of laminated glass, a type of glass that is strengthened through a unique process. The laminated glass used in impact windows consists of a layer of polyvinyl butyral (PVB) or SentryGlas Plus (SGP) sandwiched between two pieces of glass. This construction helps to keep the glass from shattering into dangerous shards if it is impacted.

Impact windows are an excellent option for homeowners who want to protect their homes from hurricane damage without installing additional shutters or taking other extreme measures. They are designed to fit into your existing masonry opening, so they don’t require any additional renovations to your home. This makes them a convenient and hassle-free option for homeowners who want to increase their home’s protection without disrupting their daily routines.

One of the great things about impact windows is that they are available in various styles and designs, so you can choose the look that best fits your home’s aesthetic. Whether you prefer traditional styles like double-hung or casement windows, or more modern styles like sliding or picture windows, there is an impact window option that will work for your home.

Another benefit of impact windows is that they can help improve your home’s energy efficiency. The laminated glass used in impact windows has insulating properties that can help to keep your home cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter. This can lead to lower energy bills and a more comfortable home environment.

Overall, impact windows are a great investment for homeowners who want to protect their homes from hurricane damage while also improving their home’s energy efficiency and overall appearance. While they may be a larger initial investment than traditional windows, they can provide long-term savings and peace of mind.

impact window manufacturer comparison

The Pros and Cons of Hurricane Shutters

Hurricane shutters Boca Raton

Like any home improvement option, hurricane shutters have their own pros and cons. Let’s take a closer look at some of them.

Pros of Hurricane Shutters:

  1. Reliability: Hurricane shutters are a reliable way to protect your windows during a hurricane. They can be installed quickly and easily, and they are available in various styles to match the look of your home.
  2. Customizable: Hurricane shutters are available in a wide range of styles, so you can choose the one that best fits your needs. Whether you want a roll-down shutter or a colonial shutter, there’s an option for you.
  3. Affordable: Hurricane shutters are generally more affordable than impact windows, which makes them a popular choice for homeowners on a budget.
  4. Easily Removable: Most types of hurricane shutters can be easily removed when they’re not needed, so they won’t impact the look of your home.

Cons of Hurricane Shutters:

  1. Hard to Handle: Some types of hurricane shutters can be difficult to handle, especially for one person. It may take at least two people to install some types of shutters, which can be a hassle.
  2. Can’t Be Installed Immediately: If you’re away from home when a hurricane hits, you won’t be able to install your hurricane shutters. This means your home will be vulnerable to damage.
  3. Little Protection Against Noise: Hurricane shutters don’t offer much protection against noise from the storm. You may still hear the wind and rain even with the shutters in place.
  4. Lock You Up: Installing shutters can make your home feel dark and confined. You may need to turn on the lights during the day, which can increase your energy bills.
  5. A Vulnerable House: Your dwelling may be left unprotected when you are out of town. 

The Pros and Cons of Impact Windows

impact windows boca raton

Now let’s take a look at the pros and cons of impact windows.

Pros of Impact Windows:

  1. Best Protection: Impact windows protect against high winds and flying debris. They are made of laminated glass that is much stronger than regular glass, so it won’t break even if a large object hits it.
  2. Ensure Safety: Impact windows provide a major barrier between you and intruders. It’s difficult for someone to break through impact glass windows, which can deter criminals from attempting a break-in.
  3. Better than Regular Glass: Impact-resistant glass is designed to withstand winds blowing up to 175mph. This means you can feel confident that your windows will stay intact during even the strongest hurricanes.
  4. Easy to Install: Impact windows can be installed quickly and easily
  5. Increase home value: They can increase the value of your home and be a good investment in the long run.
  6. Improved Noise Reduction: Improved Noise Reduction: One of the benefits of impact windows that is often overlooked is that they can help to reduce the amount of outside noise that enters your home. The laminated glass used in impact windows has sound-dampening properties that can help to block out noise from traffic, neighbors, and other external sources.
  7. Homeowners insurance benefits: Installing impact windows can often lead to lower homeowners insurance costs. This is because impact windows are designed to withstand the impact of high winds and flying debris, which means that they can help to reduce the risk of damage to your home during a hurricane or other severe weather event. 

Cons of Impact Windows:

  1. Expensive: They are more expensive than hurricane shutters and require professional installation.
  2. Permanent solution: They are a permanent solution and cannot be removed like hurricane shutters.
  3. Replacement costs: If they get damaged, they require replacement, which can be costly.

The Verdict: Hurricane Shutters or Impact Windows?

Impact window consultation Broward County

So, do you need hurricane shutters if you have impact windows?

If you live in an area with a high risk of hurricanes and storms, impact glass may be the best investment for your home. Several factors should go into consideration before making a final decision, though:

1) Budget 

Installation cost is a significant consideration when choosing between hurricane shutters and impact windows. Although hurricane shutters are typically less expensive, impact windows offer long-term savings and may be more affordable in the long run. Consider your budget and determine which option is best for your needs.

2) Home Style

Your home’s style and architecture should also be considered when choosing between hurricane shutters and impact windows. Hurricane shutters come in various styles to fit any home’s look but can detract from its aesthetics. 

On the other hand, impact windows provide a seamless and modern look to your home, and they increase your home’s curb appeal.

3) Ease of Use

Hurricane shutters can be hard to install and require extra effort to open and close when needed. Impact windows, on the other hand, provide round-the-clock protection without the hassle of having to install or remove anything. They are easily integrated into your home and require little maintenance, giving you peace of mind.

4) Protection Level

Hurricane shutters offer significant protection but may not offer the same level of protection as impact windows. Impact windows are designed to withstand high-force winds and debris, making them the ultimate protection for your home. They also offer additional benefits like UV protection, noise reduction, and intruder resistance.

Whether you need hurricane shutters or impact windows depends on your home’s unique needs and your preferences. If you want a cost-effective solution that provides some protection against hurricane winds, then hurricane shutters are an excellent option. 

However, impact windows are the way to go if you’re looking for long-term protection against all types of weather events and other perils. Regardless of your choice, investing in a protection plan for your home is always a smart move. With the proper protection, you can rest easy knowing your home, family, and belongings are safe from any storm that comes your way.

If You Choose Impact Windows – Choose an Experienced, Local Installer

STS Window impact window installation Boca Raton

If you’re in the market for hurricane protection in Boca Raton, West Palm Beach, and Broward County at-large, impact windows are a great investment that can offer your home added security and value. However, choosing the right installer is just as important as choosing the right product.

STS Windows and Doors is a local Florida company with deep experience in the industry. Their team of experts can guide you through the entire process of selecting and installing impact windows that meet your unique needs and budget.

Not only do they offer a wide selection of top-quality products, but they also provide top-notch customer service and professional installation services. With STS Windows and Doors, you can know that your investment is in good hands.

So, if you’re considering impact windows for your home, choose an experienced, local installer like STS Windows and Doors. Schedule your free consultation today!

Learn More About Impact Windows With These Helpful Resources:

Loved it? Share

Get Free Quote

Click on the button below to request a free quote on your next window or door choice.

The STS Way

Take advantage of our special discount and free quote service. Learn about the STS way today